Sestroretsk also happens to be a former favorite resort city for the who’s who of Russia's Communist Party. Because of this city's status during Soviet times, dachas* - typically modest houses and small plots of land - are transmogrified to enormous stately mansions on two or more acres of land.
These mansions are beautiful; more accurately, these mansions were beautiful and some still are. Some older structures have been maintained and still have the glory they had some fifty years ago. Some have been razed and replaced by modern, very expensive buildings. Some are relics of yore and have been abandoned and, even in some cases, have fire damage.
The location of these mansions is idyllic. The maintained or new properties prove that there are a sufficient number of wealthy builders that are keeping Sestroretsk beautiful. The surprise is the high number of abandoned buildings. The question is why they are there; more precisely, the question is why are not more of them sold to would-be-buyers who could and would invest in them to maintain their soundness and beauty.
Clearly, one answer is that the price is too high, thereby limiting the pool of buyers to the ultra-wealthy. The "high-priced real estate" phenomenon, however, is not unique to Sestroretsk. Per my experience, all of Russia has surprisingly high real estate prices as measured by American standards. In the US (before the housing bubble where sanity prevailed), the rule of thumb was that houses should cost somewhere between three to four times the annual household income. As such, a family making $100,000 per year would be expected to live in a house that cost $300,000 - $400,000. My casual observation indicates that the house price to annual income ratio is far higher in Russia, and in some cases close to infinity (because income is nearly zero).
The question thus becomes "why are houses so expensive in Russia?"
While the complete answer is, like most things in life, complex, most of the answer, like most things in life, is simple. Basically, it comes down to property taxes, or the lack there of.
In the US, one pays the government for the privilege of owning a house. This property tax is different in different regions of the US, but tends to be 1% to 1.5% in most places. The family making $100,000 and living in the $300,000 house above would have to pay some at least $3,000 of annual taxes for living in the house. That is at least a 3% income loss, and a significant loss if there is the family has a small discretionary budget. Accordingly, the family living in the house has to generate enough cash annually to pay for all expenses and property taxes. Therefore, if rich Uncle Oswald bequeaths a mansion to poor Nephew Norman, and Norman does not have the income to support the property tax, you can be sure that Oswald's estate would be on the market and sold to the highest bidder that would show up within a reasonable amount of time.
Because there are effectively no property taxes in Russia**, there is no need to have the wherewithal to sustain a property after it has been acquired***. This makes housing prices at least inelastic in Russia (or it may even increase prices) as owners with no immediate need to sell and can hold on to the property indefinitely until the buyer with the "right" price - as defined by them - comes along. The more patient the owner is, the higher the price he can command.
Unfortunately for the average Russian, there are too many patient owners and too many ultra-wealthy Russians. Owners are patient because there is no property tax to motivate them to dump their properties on the market, thereby drive prices down. And because of the very uneven income distribution in Russia, there are those elite few who can buy what they want at very high prices. These factors conspire to pump up prices of new home purchases beyond the reach of the average Russian.
Patient owners, immune from foreclosure fears, are waiting for one of those rich Russians to come along and pay the "right" price. Thus, you have a checkerboard of beautifully-maintained or newly-constructed mansions next to dilapidated former estates in Sestroretsk.
-----
* Dachas are summer residences that are nearly universally owned by every Russian family. They are located out of the city in a nearby forest.
** There are some minimum property taxes but, compared to the US, those taxes are effectively zero.
*** Acquisition may come through a purchase, an inheritance, or otherwise. The point is that it does not matter how the house is acquired because property taxes should apply uniformly, regardless of the method of acquisition, to the owner.
----
Addendum
Just for the fun of it, I have tried to model the interaction described above. The model is raw and needs more work; currently, it looks like this:
t is the time the owner is willing to wait to sell his property. The more patient the owner, the larger t is.
I is the owner's income in real terms.
T is the tax burden (not the tax rate) in real terms.
P is the owner's property value.
t is a function of T and I. In other words, t = F(T, I).
If I is much larger than T, t approaches infinity (the owner is very patient if his income dwarfs his tax burden, as I have witnessed for many owners in Russia). However, the closer in size I and T get, the smaller t gets. And if I is smaller than T - as was the case for nephew Norman above - the owner is operating on short time and we can expect a fire sale. So,
t = F(I, T) = (I / T) n where n > 0 and is descriptive of endogenous factors that may increase (n > 1), decrease (1 > n > 0), or have no impact (n = 1) on the owner's patience.
Now things get raw.
P is a function of t and x. In other words P = Q(t, x), where x is a catch-all for the time being that describes several exogenous market factors that determine market prices such as economic or political stability, expected inflation rate, foreign exchange rates, and so forth.
It is clear that the size of P (house price) and the size of t (owner's patience) are correlated. Hence, the larger t, the larger P tends to be and vice versa. It is still not clear whether the relationship of t and x with P is in terms of price elasticity or whether t and x actually determine the value of P. The answer largely depends on how x and Q are defined.
I have to noodle on this some more. Comments welcome.
Eleven posts in August. Zero posts in September. Not only are the posts enjoyable and entertaining, but also the above suggests an equation:
ReplyDeleteN=f(doesnt-care-for-his-readers-anymore, month)
where month is an integer 1-12 inclusive, and caring seems to decline seriously for month=9.
I actually understood the estate-pricing equation for about 10 minutes, but it's been so long I can hardly even remember it. At the time I thought there was a missing variable somewhere. Now I think there's just a missing author.
WoW!! We don't pay tax like the Americans and Russians do...
ReplyDeleteIn England we pay a one off fee of a very little percent to the government when we first buy the property and that's it.
We pay a annual fee to the local council for rubbish clearence and street cleaning etc..
I think you guys are getting ripped off.
I am happy to find this post Very useful for me, as it contains lot of information. thanks
ReplyDeleteWeb Development & Digital Marketing Company | Custom Web Application Development Companyy | Magento Theme Customization Service
I am incapable of reading articles online very often, but I’m happy I did today. It is very well written, and your points are well-expressed. I request you warmly, please, don’t ever stop writing. blog de proptech
ReplyDeleteHere is the investors contact Email details,lfdsloans@outlook.com. Or Whatsapp +1 989-394-3740 that helped me with loan of 90,000.00 Euros to startup my business and I'm very grateful,It was really hard on me here trying to make a way as a single mother things hasn't be easy with me but with the help of Le_Meridian put smile on my face as i watch my business growing stronger and expanding as well.I know you may surprise why me putting things like this here but i really have to express my gratitude so anyone seeking for financial help or going through hardship with there business or want to startup business project can see to this and have hope of getting out of the hardship..Thank You.
ReplyDeleteThanks so much for this information. I have to let you know I concur on several of the points you make here and others may require some further review, but I can see your viewpoint. Maid Service
ReplyDeletewebsite designer in Noida Ghaziabad
ReplyDeleteThrough this Digital Marketing Institute in Panchkula, you will become an expert in modules such as SEO, Social Media Marketing, PPC, Analytics, Content, Mobile, and Email Marketing. Our Social Media Marketing and PPC courses in Panchkula have trained end number of students. Work on real-world projects, learn the latest tools, and attend masterclasses led by the Google and Facebook certified team.
ReplyDelete- Get hands-on training on live projects!
- Upgrade your resume
- Get prepared for your dream job.
- 120+ hours of high-quality training.
- 10+ live projects.
- 25+ digital marketing tools and platforms.
Call: +91 9887046666
Location: SCO-9, First Floor, Sector-11, Panchkula, Haryana 134109
Email: info@g-sol.net
Timings: 10:00 AM TO 12:00 PM
A real estate professional should be consulted if you want to sell your home. Considering that you will be represented by a real estate agent throughout the process. He'll set up meetings with potential customers and assist you in marketing yourself as quickly as possible. When it comes to selling your house, he'll make sure you receive the best price possible. To find the most qualified agents, go to the Casanova website.
ReplyDeleteWow, Great, your articles are really very informative and easy to understand. What is a Turkish visa ? Do you have any idea about Turkish visa for US citizens ? Not more, but I suggest you 1 idea . Don't waste your time behind the old and physical visa system. A new e visa system is developed and it is very successful .It makes your journey easier and better.
ReplyDeleteSmm panel
ReplyDeleteSmm Panel
iş ilanları
İNSTAGRAM TAKİPÇİ SATIN AL
HIRDAVATÇI BURADA
beyazesyateknikservisi.com.tr
Servis
JETON HİLE İNDİR
Get amazing digital marketing services from the Best Digital Marketing Company in Zirakpur. Boost your sales, leads, and traffic at a very affordable price.
ReplyDeleteOur Services:
Website development Company in Zirakpur
Application development Company in Zirakpur
Graphic designing Company in Zirakpur
Social Media Company in Zirakpur
Contact Information:
Name: GS Web Technologies: Website, Mobile App Development, Graphic Designing and Digital Marketing Company in Zirakpur, India.
Address: 3rd Floor, Paras Down Town Square Mall, Zirakpur, Punjab – 140603, India.
Phone Number: +91- 9501406707
Good content. You write beautiful things.
ReplyDeletehacklink
vbet
korsan taksi
sportsbet
hacklink
vbet
taksi
sportsbet
mrbahis
Success Write content success. Thanks.
ReplyDeletekralbet
kıbrıs bahis siteleri
betmatik
canlı slot siteleri
betturkey
betpark
canlı poker siteleri
شركة تنظيف منازل
ReplyDeleteشركة تنظيف منازل
fethiye
ReplyDeletekağıthane
kuşadası
maltepe
şirinevler
Q44M
yurtdışı kargo
ReplyDeleteresimli magnet
instagram takipçi satın al
yurtdışı kargo
sms onay
dijital kartvizit
dijital kartvizit
https://nobetci-eczane.org/
ELK8GK
ısparta
ReplyDeletetunceli
ağrı
ığdır
samsun
DYB5O
Diyarbakır
ReplyDeleteKırklareli
Kastamonu
Siirt
Diyarbakır
UZBM
Konya
ReplyDeleteKayseri
Malatya
Elazığ
Tokat
CJ0HP
yozgat
ReplyDeletesivas
bayburt
van
uşak
4A36Jİ
goruntulu show
ReplyDeleteücretli
5LF6
https://titandijital.com.tr/
ReplyDeletetunceli parça eşya taşıma
ordu parça eşya taşıma
aydın parça eşya taşıma
van parça eşya taşıma
MH7Z4
https://titandijital.com.tr/
ReplyDeletetunceli parça eşya taşıma
ordu parça eşya taşıma
aydın parça eşya taşıma
van parça eşya taşıma
0XSGGN
ankara parça eşya taşıma
ReplyDeletetakipçi satın al
antalya rent a car
antalya rent a car
ankara parça eşya taşıma
L41
hatay evden eve nakliyat
ReplyDeleteısparta evden eve nakliyat
erzincan evden eve nakliyat
muğla evden eve nakliyat
karaman evden eve nakliyat
HVC5E
urfa evden eve nakliyat
ReplyDeletemalatya evden eve nakliyat
burdur evden eve nakliyat
kırıkkale evden eve nakliyat
kars evden eve nakliyat
RJT8
F3B3D
ReplyDeleteAksaray Lojistik
Samsun Evden Eve Nakliyat
Ağrı Evden Eve Nakliyat
İstanbul Lojistik
Antep Evden Eve Nakliyat
5AEE4
ReplyDeleteÇanakkale Parça Eşya Taşıma
Edirne Evden Eve Nakliyat
Bitlis Lojistik
Tekirdağ Parça Eşya Taşıma
İstanbul Lojistik
24C4C
ReplyDeleteErzurum Evden Eve Nakliyat
Bursa Evden Eve Nakliyat
Siirt Lojistik
Tekirdağ Parça Eşya Taşıma
Trabzon Parça Eşya Taşıma
FB1D3
ReplyDeleteSilivri Duşa Kabin Tamiri
Kırklareli Evden Eve Nakliyat
Malatya Evden Eve Nakliyat
Sinop Evden Eve Nakliyat
Niğde Evden Eve Nakliyat
6BA9A
ReplyDeleteAmasya Evden Eve Nakliyat
Kars Şehirler Arası Nakliyat
Gümüşhane Şehirler Arası Nakliyat
Coin Nedir
Osmaniye Şehir İçi Nakliyat
İstanbul Lojistik
Kırşehir Şehirler Arası Nakliyat
Afyon Şehir İçi Nakliyat
Trabzon Evden Eve Nakliyat
8022F
ReplyDeleteAntep Şehir İçi Nakliyat
Ankara Parke Ustası
Yenimahalle Fayans Ustası
Eryaman Fayans Ustası
Diyarbakır Lojistik
Uşak Şehir İçi Nakliyat
Ünye Organizasyon
Balıkesir Evden Eve Nakliyat
Çerkezköy Çekici
3A0DE
ReplyDeletetestosterone propionat
Düzce Evden Eve Nakliyat
Tokat Evden Eve Nakliyat
Adıyaman Evden Eve Nakliyat
Karaman Evden Eve Nakliyat
Coin Nedir
Şırnak Evden Eve Nakliyat
Kütahya Evden Eve Nakliyat
Kripto Para Nedir
1944E
ReplyDeleteBartın Şehir İçi Nakliyat
Sivas Şehirler Arası Nakliyat
Adana Şehirler Arası Nakliyat
Floki Coin Hangi Borsada
Kırıkkale Şehir İçi Nakliyat
Zonguldak Evden Eve Nakliyat
Coin Nedir
Düzce Parça Eşya Taşıma
MEME Coin Hangi Borsada
FE039
ReplyDeleteKripto Para Borsaları
Ankara Parke Ustası
Cointiger Güvenilir mi
Bitlis Evden Eve Nakliyat
Aksaray Evden Eve Nakliyat
Çankaya Boya Ustası
Batman Evden Eve Nakliyat
Iğdır Şehir İçi Nakliyat
Trabzon Parça Eşya Taşıma
3599D
ReplyDeleteKırklareli Şehir İçi Nakliyat
Altındağ Fayans Ustası
Uşak Parça Eşya Taşıma
Paribu Güvenilir mi
Diyarbakır Lojistik
Adana Şehirler Arası Nakliyat
Mamak Parke Ustası
Edirne Şehir İçi Nakliyat
Burdur Şehir İçi Nakliyat
085D1
ReplyDeleteKırklareli Evden Eve Nakliyat
Mefa Coin Hangi Borsada
Bursa Parça Eşya Taşıma
Düzce Şehirler Arası Nakliyat
Konya Lojistik
Kripto Para Borsaları
Adana Şehir İçi Nakliyat
Bayburt Evden Eve Nakliyat
Siirt Şehir İçi Nakliyat
E08D9
ReplyDeleteprimobolan for sale
Kastamonu Lojistik
Bayburt Şehir İçi Nakliyat
Ağrı Şehirler Arası Nakliyat
Ağrı Parça Eşya Taşıma
Gümüşhane Parça Eşya Taşıma
Eskişehir Evden Eve Nakliyat
Rize Parça Eşya Taşıma
sustanon for sale
CAF0D
ReplyDeleteİzmir Evden Eve Nakliyat
Ünye Oto Boya
Bitlis Evden Eve Nakliyat
Çerkezköy Çelik Kapı
Çerkezköy Cam Balkon
Eskişehir Evden Eve Nakliyat
Yenimahalle Fayans Ustası
Binance Referans Kodu
Kastamonu Evden Eve Nakliyat
66C01
ReplyDeleteKastamonu Parça Eşya Taşıma
testosterone propionat for sale
Artvin Lojistik
Karabük Parça Eşya Taşıma
Ankara Şehirler Arası Nakliyat
Ankara Lojistik
Burdur Evden Eve Nakliyat
order steroids
Kayseri Parça Eşya Taşıma
6C756
ReplyDelete%20 komisyon indirimi
6C018
ReplyDelete%20 referans kodu
79ADB
ReplyDeleteKripto Para Çıkarma Siteleri
Binance Para Kazanma
Bitcoin Hesap Açma
Binance Nasıl Oynanır
Bitcoin Kazanma
Coin Nasıl Çıkarılır
Yeni Çıkan Coin Nasıl Alınır
Binance Kimin
Bitcoin Nasıl Çıkarılır
CA170
ReplyDeletebinance referans kodu
resimli magnet
binance referans kodu
resimli magnet
binance referans kodu
binance referans kodu
referans kimliği nedir
referans kimliği nedir
resimli magnet
19307
ReplyDeletekırşehir canlı görüntülü sohbet uygulamaları
amasya görüntülü canlı sohbet
antalya canlı sohbet ücretsiz
trabzon canlı sohbet odası
çanakkale telefonda rastgele sohbet
malatya rastgele canlı sohbet
urfa muhabbet sohbet
bartın sohbet siteleri
çorum en iyi ücretsiz sohbet uygulamaları
51AC8
ReplyDeleteamasya canlı görüntülü sohbet
uşak mobil sohbet et
urfa sesli sohbet mobil
diyarbakır mobil sesli sohbet
görüntülü sohbet yabancı
tunceli parasız görüntülü sohbet
çanakkale yabancı canlı sohbet
ığdır sohbet uygulamaları
burdur canlı görüntülü sohbet siteleri
1A112
ReplyDeletetokat canlı sohbet bedava
bursa canli goruntulu sohbet siteleri
kastamonu görüntülü sohbet
ücretsiz görüntülü sohbet
adana kadınlarla görüntülü sohbet
manisa sohbet siteleri
random görüntülü sohbet
mobil sohbet siteleri
ücretsiz sohbet uygulamaları
شركة تنظيف مساجد بالرياض
ReplyDeleteشركة تنظيف مساجد
45F59
ReplyDeletekredi kartı ile kripto para alma
binance ne demek
rastgele canlı sohbet
kripto telegram
btcturk
bitmex
bybit
https://kapinagelsin.com.tr/
paribu